Keeping and Motivating Your Volunteers

BY: Dietrich Kirk


Volunteers, a precious resource we can’t afford to lose. —Denise Penn

Do your volunteers know how much you appreciate them? They should. Lack of volunteer appreciation is a major reason for high turnover rates among volunteers, and appreciation can be directly tied to retention. Retention is huge for all organizations that heavily rely on volunteers but especially for youth ministry for three reasons:

  1. Cost. Volunteers are free, right? Wrong! Take a moment to consider the amount of time it takes to recruit and train a new volunteer to do the job that a current volunteer is already doing.
  2. Relationships. In youth ministry, our volunteers’ relationships with the youth make the program. We know how detrimental a revolving door of relationships is to a young person. We also know the impact, influence, and stability that long-term relationships provide.
  3. Faith development. The research from the National Study of Youth and Religion and Fuller‘s College Transition Project point out the significance of these relationships to faith development or Sticky Faith.


When you evaluate the cost of losing volunteers, can you afford for volunteer retention to not move up your priority list?

People feel appreciated and are motivated in a variety of ways. Here are some things you can do to show your appreciation, based on the three primary ways people are motivated.

Some folks are competitive and therefore motivated by accomplishments, so you can appreciate these folks by:


Others are motivated by social interaction:


Finally, there are those who are motivated by influence/power:


Of course, people overlap into more than one of these groups. I bring these up to remind us that not every form of appreciation works with every personality type. Take time to think about how each of your volunteers might best be acknowledged and appreciated.

The things that are truly a priority in your ministry are the ones on your to-do list. So, if volunteer retention is a priority, then make sure its on your to-do list.

Appreciation can be done in hundreds of different ways. Here are 10 that I’ve found effective. Add your suggestions in the comments section below!

  1. Personal thank you notes (works every time)
  2. Send them a picture of them in action (in a Bible study, on a trip, hanging with students during youth group) with a note reminding them of the impact they are making on teens’ lives
  3. Pay for them to participate in youth activities, retreats, and mission trips. They are making sacrifices to be there. Show your appreciation by not making finances an issue.
  4. Gift card to their favorite coffee shop or restaurant.
  5. Volunteer celebration at youth group. Let the youth show their appreciation by serving the volunteers in some way.
  6. Monthly volunteer spotlight in your newsletter.
  7. Annual ministry celebration dinner that highlights the ways God has been at work in and through your shared ministry.
  8. Give them a certificate. Make one up on your computer as a fun way to recognize their work.
  9. Leave them a voicemail.
  10. Have the youth write them notes of gratitude.


Karen Chase2:55 pm

One way that I show appreciation to my volunteers is by making <a href="">Custom Pins </a> for each of them. It's a simple way to say thanks and to recognize all of the hard work they've done.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Articles


Theology Together: An Invitation Into Our Community


CYMT is excited about its newest endeavor, Theology Together. Theology Together educates both teenagers and youth workers as they engage in theological reflection, spiritual practice, vital service, and vocational discernment. The Theology Together process produces reflective action that is embedded in the fabric of youth ministry in all of its contexts. We believe strongly that youth are theologians and belong at the center of tough, life-changing dialogue around faith, relationships, and life. We place teenagers in the driver seat alongside their youth pastors and leaders, equipping each individual to think differently about youth ministry, to provoke a sense of awe and wonder: a WOW moment.

Youth Theology Tools | How to Position Youth as Theologians Using the WOW Theological Method


Youth theology is theology built upon the simple doctrinal principle of the priesthood of all believers, and takes that principle right down to its natural conclusion:  that all believers, including youth, teens, adolescents, etc. are theologians. It is theology that values all youth as theologians. Here we will share with you how to engage with youth theology in your own ministry.

Youth Encounter a ‘Disorienting Dilemma’ at My Cup of Tea


A few weeks ago, we shared the launch of Theology Together 2.0. Today, Dwight (the director of Theology Together) will be sharing with us one experience […]